Warning: include(/exodus/home/athena/includes/_gtmHead.php): Failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /raid/home/athena/resource/27955/interactive/index.html on line 59

Warning: include(): Failed opening '/exodus/home/athena/includes/_gtmHead.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/local/php-8.2.36/lib/php') in /raid/home/athena/resource/27955/interactive/index.html on line 59

Warning: include(/exodus/home/athena/includes/_gtmBody.php): Failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /raid/home/athena/resource/27955/interactive/index.html on line 64

Warning: include(): Failed opening '/exodus/home/athena/includes/_gtmBody.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/local/php-8.2.36/lib/php') in /raid/home/athena/resource/27955/interactive/index.html on line 64
overview image

Women’s empowerment, population dynamics, and socioeconomic development have been studied extensively from a variety of disciplines for decades, but attempts to reconcile these perspectives have been rare, particularly in terms of applying a holistic view to the relationships and dynamics. The lack of consensus limits the extent to which these concepts can be applied toward accomplishing global health and development goals.

This report looks to advance the state of knowledge on the impact of women’s empowerment and associated population dynamics on socioeconomic development by developing a conceptual framework describing these dynamics and setting an agenda for future policy-relevant research and data collection.

Working Definitions


icon

Empowerment

Empowerment is the expansion and safeguarding of an individual's or group's ability to make strategic life choices and to act on these choices to reach self-determined or collective goals.

icon

Women’s Empowerment

Women’s empowerment is the application of empowerment to women and girls specifically, recognizing that women’s empowerment may occur in the context of restrictive gender norms and gender bias in structures and institutions that disadvantage cis-gender heterosexual women as well as lesbian..., gay, bisexual, transgender, queer and/or questioning, intersex, and other (LGBTQI+) individuals, relative to cis-gender heterosexual men. Women’s empowerment may be expressed or experienced differently across specific identities, for example based on race/ethnicity, caste, class, and religion.

icon

Agency

Agency is an individual or collective’s ability to act upon personal or shared aspirations toward the realization of self-determined or collectively determined goals. Agency is the component of empowerment that connects enabling resources and aspirations to achievements. It operates at multiple levels: individual, interpersonal, community, and societal.

icon

Population Dynamics

Population dynamics include the growth, composition, and distribution of the population, and the contributing roles of fertility, mortality, and migration, either globally or in given geographic areas. Analyses of population dynamics are typically quantitative and consider factors affecting fertility, mortality, and migration from the individual to the population level.

icon

Socioeconomic Development

Socioeconomic development is the process and achievement of social and economic advancement at the individual, household, community, and societal levels. This process includes improvements in standards of living, education, health, civil engagement, and state capacity.

The Framework


This new conceptual framework highlights the central role of women’s agency at the societal, community, interpersonal, and intrapersonal levels. The framework shows how resources can support empowerment and illustrates the role of population dynamics as a potential mechanism for empowerment to influence socioeconomic development. These relationships are often bidirectional or otherwise interrelated. The framework also recognizes the sociocultural environment, including norms, institutions, and other structural conditions, as a critical moderator of the women’s empowerment process and its relations with other constructs in the model. Equitable development goals in the framework describe aspirational development goals anticipated when basic needs are met, human capabilities are realized, and human rights are guaranteed.

Recommendations


Improving Measurement

Inconsistencies, limitations, and gaps in measurement are a primary barrier to advancing knowledge on the role of women’s empowerment in population dynamics and socioeconomic development and subsequent targeted interventions that increase empowerment.

  • Recommendation 1

    Data collection on women’s empowerment should be expanded to include the range of measures necessary to fully capture elements of women’s empowerment, as well as the dynamics and pathways in the committee’s framework that remain poorly understood. Many of these aspects are multidimensional and should be understood as such. These include:

    • Sociocultural norms and structures as conditioning factors in the sociocontextual environment.
    • Structural dynamics and sexism.
    • The role of men, including structural gender inequalities, inequitable gender norms, and masculine dominance.
    • Barriers to empowerment.
    • Effective methods to reduce gender inequality in productivity, earnings, and profits.
    • Effective methods to address norms surrounding women's domestic work.
    • Effective methods to eliminate occupational segregation.
    • Effective methods to build resilience for women in the face of climate change and other shocks.
    • Women’s access to health programs (e.g., social protection, insurance, contraception, prenatal and childbirth care, infant and child healthcare, women’s healthcare).
    • Girls’ and women’s education and skill building.
    • Girls’ and women’s social networks and supports.
    • Couple dynamics.
    • Perceptions of rights.
    • Time allocation and control over time.
  • Recommendation 2

    Researchers and government data-collection entities studying women’s empowerment should identify opportunities to collect longitudinal data from large-scale studies to better understand change over time, including the determinants of sustained gains in women's empowerment and the long-term effects of women's empowerment on socioeconomic development.

  • Recommendation 3

    Research should prioritize the development of direct multidimensional, construct-specific, and multilevel measures of agency. To the extent that proxy measures are used, researchers should strive for consistency and clarity on how such measures are defined and used, and they should be clear that the role of women’s agency is assumed and not directly measured. Particular attention should be paid to defining, operationalizing, and assessing the reliability and validity of the following dimensions of women’s agency in diverse contexts, leveraging the newest research:

    • Individual awareness of rights, aspirations and preferences, goal setting and choice, internal motivation.
    • Control and decision making, including economic and reproductive decision making, at the individual and interpersonal levels.
    • Collective agency in formal groups and informal networks at the community and societal levels (e.g., shared goals, collective efficacy, collective action toward shared goals). 
  • Recommendation 4

    Research on agency should include studies of women’s agency across the entire life course and at key life stages and milestones, with consideration of the socioecological and cultural context and intergenerational influences on key life stages, milestones, and inflection points.

Enhancing Study Designs

Improved study designs could enhance understanding of the role of women’s empowerment by capturing the highly dynamic nature of the interactions, disentangle exposure from outcomes, and establish causality.

  • Recommendation 5

    Research on women’s empowerment and agency should prioritize study designs that:

    • Test causal relationships between dimensions of women’s empowerment and population dynamics and socioeconomic development, and that better elucidate the role of relevant concepts as causal factors or outcomes. These designs include randomized controlled trials, quasi-experiments, natural experiments, and longitudinal designs to establish causality; to examine reciprocal, temporal relationships; and to distinguish effects related to the mode of intervention delivery and quality of implementation from the content of the intervention.
    • Include qualitative data collection to contextualize theories of change, to inform intervention and research design, and to aid in the interpretation of findings that offer causal evidence.
    • Are informed by the perspectives of the women and communities being studied.
    • Examine multiple intervention points along the theoretical pathways of interest.
    • Provide understanding of life-course trajectories and inflection points.
  • Recommendation 6

    Research funders should support studies designed to examine the effects of programs and policies intended to enhance women’s empowerment and, thereby, socioeconomic development. Study designs should include sufficient follow-up time to examine sustainability of impacts, as well as measures that permit assessment of unintended adverse effects of interventions, including outcomes (both intended and unintended) that may not be immediate.

  • Recommendation 7

    To establish external validity, more attention should be devoted to understanding the role of interventions and the specific role of women’s agency as a mechanism for social change—at the institutional and societal levels, as well as across diverse cultural settings. Also, more attention should be paid to understanding the feasibility, acceptability, and sustainability of, as well as engagement with, these interventions.

  • Recommendation 8

    Studies are needed to better understand the impacts of integrated approaches to women’s empowerment (e.g., cash transfers to women alongside efforts to address restrictive social and gender norms) and integrated women’s healthcare (e.g., service-delivery models that can address women’s sexual and reproductive health as well as psychosocial care needs).

  • Recommendation 9

    Research funders should support cost analyses and implementation science studies to provide guidance on scaling up efficacious interventions. Such efforts should include systematic tracking of program-implementation data. As evidence from experimental studies continues to grow, comparative effectiveness studies may provide best-practice guidance to government officials and civil society organizations regarding the most cost-effective empowerment approaches in specific country contexts.

Collaboration and Harmonization

Comparable data, collected across diverse contexts, are essential for drawing cross-cultural and cross-national comparisons and arriving at conclusions. The interdisciplinary nature of this field further highlights the importance of collaboration to set priorities, coordinate research efforts, and refine measurement approaches that can expedite insights into these questions.

  • Recommendation 10

    Research funders should establish an international, multidisciplinary group to increase coordination and priority setting for the work in this area. The advisory group could include representatives of funding organizations and other experts and stakeholders, and it would be charged with:

    • Developing and publishing standards and best practices for development and validation of measures for empowerment, so researchers and implementers can better distinguish among the array of measures in use.
    • Coordinating work on psychometric assessment of measures of empowerment and related concepts, and evaluating the possibility of (and recommended processes for) harmonizing measures and global indicators of women’s agency and empowerment that would be suitable for comparative use cross-culturally and with various populations.
    • Identifying questions and measures that improve measurement of specific empowerment constructs in specific cultures and languages.
    • Setting priorities for development of experimental studies to generate causal evidence on relationships that currently are not well understood.
  • Recommendation 11

    Government, program, and researcher data collections should be better coordinated and aligned. The international group described above could facilitate efforts to enhance coordination and alignment across these groups.

Learn More